Coda wrote:Back to the Future contradicted itself in that regard. Its explanation for "temporal grace" was that the timeline forked, and you end up traveling on the fork you didn't originate on -- your own history is, essentially, intact; it's just not the history of the world you're actually observing. But then they had the "fading" thing happen, which was great for movie magic but really didn't make much sense in light of the "alternate timeline" explanation.
Yeah... yes! I never caught that. I think it just shined on past me. Good insight, and catch, Coda.
Hmmm... is there a way out of this? I can't think of anything different in terms of
how they traveled to get to that alternate universe timeline. There wasn't some new button pressed. This is a tough one to do a No-Prize for. There is no difference I can find between the way Marty changed the past and the way Tannen changed it... so the fading thing just doesn't make sense - it's an entirely different time mechanic.
SO, Can I Do It?The fading hand can only 'work' if the Delorean is only able to travel within one, single, solitary timeline. Even then, there is no explanation for the slow effect of the temporal changes occurring - they should be instant. And unnoticed - memory too, would be changed. Here's a
No-Prize answer... Flux Capacitors spew temporal radiation which poisons matter around it; such chronoradioactive matter is forced partially outside time, and thus changes in causality must overcome that radiation pressure to finally affect said matter - thus the slow-fading hand. There.
But the Tannen problem... hmmm...
How about this!
Chronoradiation is cumulative. It builds up in matter, forcing that matter further and further out of sync with its original timestream. The effect is such that only one, perhaps two trips can ever be taken in linear time before the time machine, and travelers, are inevitably forced out of their original worldline by chronoradiative pressure.
The reason, then, that Biff Tannen seemed to create an alternate version of history, a parallel reality, is because... he
didn't. Biff just altered the original BTTF timeline, the end. But for Marty and Doc Brown, already heavily dosed with chronons, it was the last straw. It would have happened with or without Tannen's actions; they were already doomed to be excluded, forever, from their original timeline, pushed out by their own chronoradioactivity. They never return, not to the world we first saw in the original BTTF movie - to the people there, Doc and Marty just vanished one day. There were hints of Libyans and dark dealings at the mall. No trace ever found.
I can prove it too!
The first hint that Marty and Doc are being pushed outside normal time into alternate timelines occurs at the very beginning of Back To The Future 2. There is a different Jennifer. It isn't that they couldn't get the same actress - oh no - rather it is the incredibly clever effort of Robert Zemeckis to prove the theory I have just presented to you. That different Jennifer is an alternate universe Jennifer from the start of the movie; they slid out of their timeline in the blink of an eye, like a watermelon seed popped from between two squeezing fingers. The moment? It happens during the exact instant that Doc is putting garbage in the Mr. Fusion machine. Then. In that instant. Tannen had nothing to do with it; in that moment Doc and Marty lost their true universe, and became refugees among an infinite number of alternate timestreams.
And I can prove it further! Robert Zemeckis made this effort to prove what I am saying now, today, at 12:45 AM, 3/16/2010 in the past, all the way back in
1988, during the filming of BTTF 2. Time travel is clearly involved here, thus proving my genius explanation!
Ooh! I'm dizzy with my own brilliance. A No-Prize is me!
I have an answer for everything; the only problem is that I am probably wrong - a
minor detail, I assure you.